Skip to content


Archives for

See all posts in the network tagged with

What did the fire chief know and when did he know it? Dennis Rubin’s answers on the fire engine/ambulance giveaway scrutinized by two reporters.

10 comments

Above is Part 1 of the April 1, 2009  hearing. Click for Part 2, Part 3 and Part 4.

Report by the Committee for Public Safety & the Judiciary

Report by the Committee for Government Operations & the Environment

Click here and scroll down for our previous coverage of the Sosua controversy

The two District of Columbia City Council reports released late last week looking into a controversial, aborted deal to donate a fire engine and ambulance to a resort town in the Dominican Republic have reporters taking a second look at the April 1, 2009 testimony of Chief Dennis Rubin. While the testimony thrust Chief Rubin into the limelight early on, making him the face of the growing controversy (not that anyone else was taking responsibility for the mess), in the end, the role of the DC Fire & EMS Department was almost secondary and not the main issue for those critical of the arrangement to use a non-profit group as a middle-man to broker the deal.

But, that doesn’t mean the role of Chief Rubin didn’t raise a few eyebrows once the reports were released. The reports include emails and other information showing that Rubin was aware and involved in the various forms of the planned donation going back to November, 2007. Eighteen months later, the chief told Committee for Public Safety and the Judiciary Chairman Phil Mendelson that he knew very little about the deal and was “clueless”. 

That testimony had some very heated and pointed exchanges between Mendelson and Rubin. You may also recall during that hearing Chief Rubin said a number of times “I take full responsibility”, but Mendelson was skeptical and ultimately correct that the responsibility for the deal actually belonged elsewhere in the administration of Mayor Adrian Fenty.

DC Rubin fireworks nationals parkTwo reporters who have covered this controversy from the start,  have taken a closer look at the fire chief’s testimony in light of the council reports and wondered if the chief failed to tell the truth under oath. Each article was published Friday.

The Examiner’s Michael Neibauer, who uncovered the donation and originally brought the story to light, starts his article this way:

Fire Chief Dennis Rubin was directly involved in the District’s donation of emergency vehicles to the Dominican Republic, newly released e-mails show, but the chief claimed under oath to know very little days after the deal fell apart. 

Later in the day, Washington City Paper’s Mike DeBonis followed-up on what Neibauer started with a column titled Did Fire Chief Dennis Rubin Perjure Himself? Nope.

DeBonis, who writes the column Loose Lips (LL),  further dissects the exchanges during the April 1 testimony and how they relate to the emails provided in the report. His conclusion:

…  from what LL sees, there’s nothing that would indicate the Rubin ever intentionally lied to Phil Mendelson’s public safety and judiciary committee.

As for Phil Mendelson’s take, he tells DeBonis, it’s not clear cut:

The at-large councilmember passed on the question of whether Rubin lied under oath, calling it “not clear-cut.” Mendelson said he’d reviewed the tape in the course of his committee’s investigation but did so some time ago.

“I’ve thought about this quite a bit, and I don’t have an answer,” he says. “It is a good question.” 

Firefighter among those detained in Haiti after a different type of rescue mission is interrupted. Topeka’s Drew Culberth part of church group hoping to bring 33 children back to U.S.

7 comments

Read more on colleague’s reactions to firefighter’s arrest

From the AP:

A firefighter from Topeka is one of 10 U.S. Baptists being held in the Haitian capital Sunday after trying to take 33 children out of Haiti.

The church members said they were trying to rescue abandoned and traumatized children. But officials said they lacked the proper documents.

One of those detained is Drew Culberth. The 34-year-old father of four from Topeka is a firefighter and assistant youth pastor at Bethel Baptist Church.

Friend Joel Culberson says a relative who leads a church in Iowa had asked Culberth to go on the trip.

News of what had happened had everybody worried, and the congregation prayed for him during services Sunday.

Culberth has concerns, but he says he knows “God is in control of the situation.”

Metal crashes through fire truck window during one of dozens of explosions in Flint. Video, pictures & details of second Michigan auto salvage business to burn in 24-hours.

3 comments

Click here for Part 2 of the video.

Listen to the initial dispatch courtesy of FireSceneAudio.com

See Bing Bird’s Eye View of the site

Fireground audio, video & details from Friday’s auto salvage business fire in Detroit

Flint Journal photo by Sarah Miller. Click the image for more pictures and details.

Flint Journal photo by Sarah A. Miller. Click the image for more pictures and details.

For the second time in about 24-hours a Michigan auto salvage and parts business has burned, setting off numerous small explosions. Friday’s fire in Detroit, went to three-alarms and kept firefighters busy for 10 hours.

The fire Saturday was reported just after 4:30 PM about 90-minutes after Inter-City Auto Parts closed for the day. The business is at 2308 Toronto Street. The salvage yard and two buildings are surrounded by railroad tracks and a neighborhood of single family homes.

On the two video clips on this page you can hear numerous explosions. A battalion chief told a local TV station there were at least 50 such blasts from propane and acetylene tanks. Shrapnel from one of the tanks smashed a window of a fire truck on the scene.

The fire is reported to have started in the office of the business and spread to the nearby warehouse. The tanks that exploded were stored inside that warehouse.

No injuries were reported.

MI Flint shrapnel

 WEYI-TV image of metal that went though the window of a Flint fire truck. Click above for more pictures.

Dairy farm fire in Adams County, Pennsylvania. Tractor fire spreads to structures.

No comments
Pictures on this page from Steve Roth, SJ Roth Photography. Click the image for more of Steve's photos from the fire.

Pictures on this page from Steve Roth, SJ Roth Photography. Click the image for more of Steve's photos from the fire.

Take a virtual tour of the JoBo Holstein Farm

A feed mixing shed was destroyed and part of a cattle barn damaged in a fire Friday evening in Adams County, Pennsylvania. The fire was at the JoBo Holstein Farm located on Tall Oaks Road. Bonneauville Community Fire Company Chief Jerry Poland reported seeing a thermal column from the firehouse two miles away as he responded to the fire at 5:19 PM.

PA Adams dairy farm 1When Chief Poland arrived, a fire that started in a tractor had spread to the feed mixing station and the cattle barn, home to 120 cows. The farm is owned by John and Bonnie Hess and their children. The cows survived.

Here are excerpts from an article by John Messeder at GettysburgTimes.com:

One of John Hess’ daughters, Josie Riser, discovered the fire in its early stages. She was coming from her home adjacent to the farm, when she rounded the feed structure and saw the John Deere payloader on fire. She called to her brother.

“He said to get some chain, and he called 9-1-1,” she said.

Her brother chained a car to the tractor and tried without success to pull it from the feed building. Josie climbed into a nearby feed truck and moved it to safety. She and her brother were clear of the tractor when fire burned into the tires and they exploded, shaking house windows a quarter mile away.

The fire rose up into a wet wind, blowing across a 50-foot open area to some large straw bales, setting them on fire.

“The owner (John Hess) and I decided to write off this (feed) building and save (the barn),” Poland said.

PA Adams dairy farm 2Steve Roth, who provided the pictures on this page,  said fire crews operated for five hours. The farm provides product for Land O’Lakes and Hershey’s.

Here are some additional details about the fire Chief Poland provided to STATter911.com:

2nd and 3rd alarms were struck within minutes, bringing additional Tankers, as the fire was located in a non-hydrant area. Two trucks were placed into operation to provide cover for the exposed buildings, and suppression efforts. A total of 11 volunteer Departments were called to the scene, as Firefighters battled 30+ mph winds, extreme ice conditions, and temperatures in the low 20’s. Two heated rehab trailers were called to the scene to provide shelter to firefighters as they rotated through after their assignments. There were no firefighter injuries reported.

Fireground audio from 3-alarm Detroit fire & explosions that burned several buildings & auto salvage yard. Hazmat scene with 1 injured firefighter & water problems.

2 comments

More pictures from the fire

Bing Bird’s Eye View of complex

Extensive photo gallery of the fire

Article by Valerie Olander, The Detroit News:

Fire engulfed several commercial buildings on the city’s west side late Friday night, including an auto parts yard with dozens of cars that set off a series of small explosions.

Photo by Ricardo Thomas of The Detroit NewsThe fire started around 9 p.m. Friday in the office of Saad Auto Parts on Schaefer Highway near Plymouth. Owner Mohamad Saad said he and his staff tried to put it out with a fire extinguisher, but “it was just too quick.”

Dozens of firefighters battled the blaze with two aerial ladder trucks, despite low water pressure because of the cold temperatures. Second Deputy Commissioner Fred Wheeler said crews from the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department arrived on the scene to address the water pressure problem.

Hazardous materials crews also were on site because of explosions from the cars’ gas tanks. Large plumes of smoke filled the night sky as some nearby residents stopped to watch the blaze.

As of late Friday, the only injury was a firefighter who was hurt when a piece of metal fell on his leg. Homes in the area appeared to be unaffected.

UPDATED – Mayday in Brooklyn during fire that killed five people. 13 firefighters hurt. Bystanders unable to catch infant dropped from window. Raw video and fireground audio from the scene in Bensonhurst.

4 comments

UPDATE – Details on the mayday at 2033 86th Street in Bensonhurst early this morning in excerpts from an article by Robert D. McFadden of  The New York Times:

Battling intense heat and smoke with streams of water from a tangle of fire engines on 86th Street, a commercial thoroughfare, firefighters finally got into the building at 3:30 a.m., an hour after their arrival. During the ensuing search of dark rooms crowded with furniture, it became apparent that structural timbers weakened by the fire were in danger of collapse.

One firefighter fell through the ground floor and became entangled in basement timbers. He was soon pulled out, but fire officials then ordered all firefighters out of the building. Shortly after the evacuation order, the interior of the building collapsed.

“They pulled them out because the roof was about to collapse,” a fire official said. “They saw that the integrity of the floor was in jeopardy, so as a precaution they pulled everyone out.”

Commissioner Cassano gave a similar account. “You have a huge hole in the floor, the stairway was burning,” he said. “We had to move them out. The firefighters that were here did their best to rescue as many people as they could.”

More from the AP:

A fire that tore through a Brooklyn building that housed mostly Guatemalan immigrants and killed at least five people on Saturday may have been intentionally set, a fire official said.

The early morning blaze is being investigated as a possible case of arson because it started behind the door of the first-floor entrance to the building, New York City Fire Commissioner Salvatore Cassano said.

“That’s not where a fire would normally start,” Cassano said after surveying the devastation of the fire, which trapped residents and caused part of the roof to collapse.

Four people in the building were injured, including an infant and a child who were tossed out the window by a woman frantically trying to save them. The infant was in critical condition with a fractured skull after bystanders below failed to catch him, officials and witnesses said. The other child landed on an awning.

At least one adult was hospitalized, and 13 firefighters were injured, none of them seriously, officials said.

The fire started around 2:30 a.m in the Bensonhurst neighborhood, home to a diverse population of Italians, Russians, Hispanics and Chinese. The flames quickly engulfed the three-story building on a busy commercial strip, consuming a ground-floor Japanese restaurant and two apartments on the upper floors.

The stairwell between the floors collapsed, as well as part of the roof, trapping residents, according to fire officials.

Most of the building’s residents were from Guatemala, neighbor Juan Gabriel told The New York Times.

As the fire raged, a woman held a baby boy out a third-floor window. Bars covered the lower half of the window, keeping the woman from climbing out, Gabriel said.

“She was screaming, ‘Help me, help me,’ ” Gabriel said. Moments later, she threw the infant out the window to Gabriel and two other men.

In the darkness, the child fell to the ground, authorities said. She then tossed another child out the window. He landed on the awning below.

It wasn’t immediately clear whether the woman survived the fire.

Chaplain for PGFD quits over direction of the department. Alvin Graham was recruited by recently fired top aide to Chief Eugene Jones.

36 comments

Click here and here for previous coverage of this issue

STATter911.com has learned that Alvin G. Graham, an ordained minister and the chaplain for the Prince George’s County Fire/EMS Department, has turned in his car and department equipment. Contacted by phone at his Upper Marlboro home, Graham, 64, confirmed he informed PGFD Chief Eugene Jones on Friday of his immediate resignation.

Graham said he was concerned about the direction of the department, particularly plans that had the chaplain corps reporting to the Employee Assistance Program (EAP) instead of directly to the fire chief. Graham believes it is important to work with EAP, but says the spiritual mission he is responsible for is something quite different.

Lt. Col. Victor Stagnaro from PGFD website.

Lt. Col. Victor Stagnaro from PGFD website.

Sources indicate that Alvin Graham is close friends with Lt. Col. Victor Stagnaro, who was fired by Chief Jones on Monday. According to the sources, it was Stagnaro who recruited Graham to fill the volunteer position.

Chief Jones said through a spokesman on Monday, that contrary to STATter911.com’s report, the departure had to do with Col. Stagnaro’s intention to retire and that Stagnaro is on leave until February 12, his retirement date.

Those familiar with the situation tell STATter911.com, that while Alvin Graham had serious concerns about the restructuring of the chaplain’s position, the timing of the firing on Monday and Graham’s resignation on Friday are not a coincidence.

PGFD Chief Spokesman Mark Brady, upon hearing the news about Chaplain Graham’s resignation, said Graham will be greatly missed. Brady told us the chaplain has been a constant presence at significant department events, both happy and sad, over the last nine years.

Alvin Graham was born in Fairmont Heights, Maryland. He moved to Seattle, Washington in 1963 and returned to Prince George’s County in 2000. Graham said he came back in an effort to make a difference in the community where he grew up.

In other PGFD news, Major Steve Hess has been named acting  lieutenant colonel of Administrative Services. This is part of the realignment after the dismissal of Stagnaro. According to sources, Human Resources, which had come under Administrative Services, has now been moved to Management Services, headed by Lt. Col. Angela Peden.

Four DeKalb County, Georgia firefighters fired over response to fire. Elderly woman dead after crews didn’t find burning house during initial response.

6 comments

More from AJC.com

More from The Secret List

Read DeKalb County report into fire response

From the AP:

Four firefighters were terminated Thursday and they are being investigated by police for their response to a house fire that killed an elderly woman.

The DeKalb County firefighters responded to a 911 call from the home about 1 a.m. Sunday and left after they didn’t see any signs of flames or smoke.

But according to an investigative report, they didn’t follow department procedure to approach the home, verify the address and make contact with the 911 caller. 

Ann Bartlett in a family photo.

Ann Bartlett in a family photo.

Most of the firefighters who responded to the call stayed in their vehicles, only getting out to help the trucks turn around in the cul-de-sac near the home, according to the report.

About six hours later, a neighbor called 911 to report the same house was fully engulfed in flames. Ann Bartlett, 74, was found dead inside from smoke inhalation.

“These officers didn’t follow policy, and that’s why they’re being terminated,” county public safety director William Z. Miller said Friday.

Police in Dunwoody, a northern Atlanta suburb, have launched a criminal investigation into the fire department’s response, police Chief Billy Grogan said.

The four firefighters are acting officer in charge William Greene, Capt. Tony L. Motes, Battalion Chief Lesley Clark and Battalion Chief Bennie J. Paige. A fifth firefighter, Capt. Sell Caldwell, has been put on leave with pay as an investigation into his actions continues, DeKalb County spokeswoman Shelia Edwards said.

Paige did not immediately return a call for comment Friday. There were no public phone listings for the rest of the firefighters and it was not known if they had retained attorneys.

Bartlett’s daughter, Ruth, said Friday she hopes “every firefighter learns from this.” She said her family wants an apology from the firefighters.

“We know those four men feel awful,” she said in a telephone interview. “First, we were very shocked. Then we were very sad, and as the facts started to unravel, we became mad. Now as we see they are resolving and taking actions they deem appropriate, we are starting to heal.”

Florida fire chief now only has one job. Kenneth Ellerbe resigned from the DC Fire & EMS Department amid controversy over his dual employment.

10 comments
Chief Kenneth Ellerbe from Sarasota County website.

Chief Kenneth Ellerbe from Sarasota County website.

Click here & scroll down for our previous coverage on this story

STATter911.com has learned that Deputy Chief Kenneth Ellerbe resigned from the District of Columbia Fire & EMS Department on January 15. The resignation came a month and a day after it was first reported by David Lipscomb of The Washington Times that Ellerbe was both the chief of the Sarasota County Fire Department and on leave without pay from DC.

That revelation was followed by our report there was a signed agreement between the two jurisdictions that allowed this unusual arrangement. Numerous sources indicated the deal was an effort to let Chief Ellerbe stay employed by the DC Fire & EMS Department until his 50th birthday in April, providing hundreds of thousands of dollars in additional retirement benefits.

DC Fire & EMS Department Chief Spokesman Pete Piringer confirmed Kenneth Ellerbe’s new status today.

Still unanswered from anyone in the District government is exactly why this arrangement was made and what advantage there was for the city in facilitating such a deal.

STATter911.com learned on December 16 that the official “Personnel Exchange Agreement” was approved in DC by Assistant Fire Chief Brian Lee and Director of Human Resources Brender Gregory. The Department of Human Resources denied a Freedom of Information Act request by STATter911.com for paperwork and correspondence related to this agreement.

As we reported last month, DC Fire & EMS Department sources indicated when the arrangement was first presented to Chief Dennis Rubin he refused to sign off on the deal. In June, when the department was questioned by STATter911.com about a possible deal to help Chief Ellerbe with his retirement, the word from a spokesman was that Chief Rubin said there would be no special arrangements for Ellerbe. The fire department sources, who are not authorized to speak on this matter, indicated in December that Chief Rubin said he only recently had become aware that Assistant Chief Lee signed the exchange form.

A dangerous return trip from the repair shop. St. Louis fire engine struck by bullet as crew drove into the line of fire.

No comments

By Jeff Small KSDK-TV:

Some St. Louis firefighters barely escaped injury after getting caught in the middle of a shooting Wednesday night in North St. Louis City.

A shooting broke out around 10:30 p.m. very close to engine house 26 in the 4200 block of Margeretta. Firefighters were on their way to their firehouse when bullets went flying.

MO St. Louis fire engine struck by bulletA spokesman for the fire department said firemen were bringing a pumper truck back to the firehouse from a repair shop. As they got close to the firehouse, they heard a loud noise.

When they looked up the street, they noticed a person with a gun firing shots at a man and woman. At least one bullet is believed to have ricocheted and hit the firefighter’s pumper truck.

“They were directly in the line of fire and the noise they heard was the bullet grazing off the pumper so they immediately backed out,” said spokesman Bob Keuss.

Firefighters involved in the shooting were not injured but police say the male victim was shot in the leg, the female shot in the back. Both were taken to the hospital where they were listed in stable condition. As of Thursday night, police were still looking for the shooter.

Quick Takes

1 comment

Fireground audio of 3-alarm Oregon fire with water supply problems: Click here for the radio traffic from FireSceneAudio.com of the fire in a large vacant early 1900s building at the Fairview Training Center in Salem. Read more.

A welcome home from Haiti: Away for 15 days, Virginia Task Force 1 helped bring 16 people to safety who were trapped in the rubble of the earthquake in Haiti. Watch the welcome the team received yesterday evening in Fairfax County. Also, click here for a slideshow of the welcome home.

Report faults firefighters for not following procedures during fatal fire: Four members of the DeKalb County Fire Department, including two captains and a battalion chief remain suspended with pay after a report puts a lot of the blame on their shoulders for failing to find the burning home of a woman who called 911 early Sunday. They did return about five hours later to find the house destroyed and the woman dead. Read the report and more details.

Woman hit by hose falls off fire engine: You had probably seen the earlier story on this one from Cambridge, Massachusetts. A loyal reader and Firegeezer alert us to the update that an 82-year-old woman died when she was hit by hose that fell off the rig as the crew was responding. Click here.

Ambulance with a very bad reputation lives up to its past and burns: The ambulance that helped push New Jersey lawmakers to widen the states “Lemon Law” to include emergency vehicles self destructed yesterday and few are surprised. Click for pictures, video and the to read the story.

Mayor and fire department director finally talking in Memphis: With the TV station into its second week of stories on hiring practices at the Memphis Fire Department, city officials are now answering some questions about the arrest of 80 firefighters over the last five year. Click for the mayor and here for Director Alivin Benson.

Fire department takes $128,000 loss on new fire engine that was just too big: Pennsylvania’s Lawrence Park Fire Department (Erie County) sold its new, 37.9-foot-long Pierce Dash Pumper just 17-months after getting the $510,000 rig. They found Engine 284 too big for the township’s alleys. And the sale has caused some controversy. Read the story

 Omaha heating up again: Loyal reader Ron Young points us to some stories out of Omaha where there has been controversy over a proposed new fire boat and other items being purchased from a special fund. Click here for that one (and an earlier article here).

The news never stops in Bourne, Massachusetts: Just when we thought things might calm down after the resignation of Lt. Kelli Weeks, there is even more controversy in the Bourne Fire Department. The acting chief now has some allegations against him. Click here for that story. Also, the firefighters’ union has some harsh words for how the town selectmen handled the Weeks affair. Check it out.

Another blue light special: In Des Moines police say a Grand Junction volunteer firefighter apparently wants to also be a volunteer police officer. The cops say 29-year-old Richard Collogan was pulling people over with his blue light. Read the details.

The wife tells me I must run this one: She was charmed about the story of a 3-year-old boy who very effectively used 911 to help her grandmother who was having a seizure. Click here for the story from Maple Shade, New Jersey and here to listen to the call and meet Jaden Bolli. We need to get Jaden to teach everyone how to be that calm when calling 911.

It is not the CNN employee I expected to do this: If there was ever someone from CNN who I could easily see an old firehouse in New York to live in,  it would be my friend, and fire buff extraordinaire, Vito Maggiolo. But the story at HuffingtonPost.com isn’t about Vito. It’s about Anderson Cooper paying $4.3 million for such a privilege. Click here for the story and pictures.

Fireground audio & video from Chicago 3-11: A very cold Steve Redick shot this fire in the cockloft of a large commercial building at 47th and King yesterday. Click here for the radio traffic from FireSceneAudio.com.  You can read more about the fire here.

A welcome home for Virginia Task Force 1.

3 comments

Above is raw video from Dulles International Airport and the Fairfax County Fire & Rescue Department Training Academy as Virginia Task Force 1 is welcomed home by family and friends. Video by Sky9 and Greg Guise.

Click here for a slideshow of the welcome home

Pictures of some of the work by the team in Haiti 

Previous coverage of the team’s mission

From Surae Chinn, WUSA9.com:

114 men and women of the Fairfax County Urban Search and Rescue team arrived home to their families.

They saved 16 lives after the deadly earthquake.

A huge crowd anxiously waited for them at the Fairfax academy on West Ox Road Thursday night.

VA Fairfax VATF1 returnsLoud cheers, smiling faces and lots of hugs and kisses to go around.

It may have only been 15 days away from home but it felt like an eternity for loved ones and the heroes who saved lives in Haiti.

As the three buses, escorted by police, turned the corner to the academy the crowd erupted.

Cindy Porter was overwhelmed with emotion.

And it just so happened Cindy’s husband, Sam, was one of the first to get off the bus.

You could see children hugging their dads a little tighter not willing to let go. The group tired, but excited too.

Their hair a little shorter after staying the night and showering in Santo Domingo before the trip home.

After their emotional reunion it didn’t take long for them to start putting their requests in.

Sam Porter yells out, “I want to get a good steak dinner!”

Rebecca Knerr, who sat by Michelle Obama at the State of the Union Wednesday night, was there to greet her husband.

Knerr says, “It’s good to have him home.”

Watch Surae Chinn’s story, above.

Jim Perkins says, “I don’t like using the term hero, we were just doing our job.”

Porter says he had to throw a lot of his clothes and a pair of boots away. Most of his memories, he says, are in his mind.

Porter says, “It makes me so proud to see my family. They were there when I left and they were there when I came back. It’s breathtaking

They all said it will take some time to decompress from the 15 days of seeing all the suffering, tragedy and the miracles.

 but they say they would do it again in a heartbeat.

Report says firefighters never walked up to house reported on fire. Five hours later home burned down with woman inside. The latest from DeKalb County, Georgia.

3 comments

Read DeKalb County Fire Investigation Report

More at FirefighterCloseCalls.com

Read more at AJC.com

As we previously reported DeKalb County, Georgia officials launched an investigation into a house fire early Sunday morning. Firefighters responded twice to Ann Bartlett’s home. It was the actions during the first response that resulted in the four fire department officers – Officer in Charge William Greene, Capt. Tony L. Motes, Capt. Sell Caldwell, and Battalion Chief Lesley Clark  being put on leave with pay. Today a report into the fire was released by DeKalb County. Here’s more from an article by Jaye Watson from WXIA-TV:

Ann Bartlett in a family photo.

Ann Bartlett in a family photo.

“Our family wants to tell you what a wonderful and kind woman my mother was.”

Ruth Bartlett and her two sisters and their children stand in front of the home their mother Ann lived in for 41 years. The 74 year old Bartlett called 911 shortly after 1 a.m. sunday morning to report that an oxygen device she used for a pulmonary condition had just set the house on fire.

In a copy of the 911 call made by Bartlett you can hear her say her name and complete address. The operator tells her to evacuate the house and then Bartlett says “hurry!” before the phone was disconnected. The operator tried repeatedly to call Barlett back to no avail.

Fire crews arrived just 12 minutes after the call but in a copy of a report from Dekalb County Fire Department Incident Investigation fire crews ‘failed to establish incident command.’ The report also says ‘Houses on either side of 1687 Houghton Court North had visible addresses, and although not in exact sequence(1691 and 1686), should have provided a clue of the location of 1687 Houghton Court North.

Ruth Bartlett, who met with County and Fire officials thursday morning,tells what happened when crews arrived.

“Those on the scene said they looked around from their trucks here in the cul de sac but did not see any evidence of fire. They observed that our family home up the hill was dark. They did not get out of their trucks and their trucks left the scene at 1:22 am seven minutes after they arrived. No one walked up this hill to her house. No one knocked on anyone’s door asking questions.”

More than five hours later at 6:40 a.m. neighbors called 911 to report Bartlett’s house engulfed in flames. Crews found her body just inside her garage.

Ruth Bartlett says, “We believe the electricity must have gone out because the phone went dead and the electric door opener for the garage would not have gone up. She perished there by the door inside the garage.”

Ruth Bartlett and her sisters can’t bear to think what if? What if the firefighters had walked up the driveway? What if they had followed the ‘360 protocol’ which calls for them to walk around the structure and look inside? They believe the firefighters would have found the fire, and their mother, alive.

Bartlett’s children have asked for a personal apology from the firefighters who left the scene. They say their mother, an Atlanta native, lived for her children and grandchildren. A horrible mistake has taken a matriarch away from her family.

“She paid her taxes in Dekalb county for 41 years but when she needed Dekalb County they did not find her. They did not find the person that made that 911 call.”

Infamous ambulance burns inside New Jersey fire & rescue building. Flanders’ rig helped extend ‘lemon law’ to emergency vehicles.

7 comments

Click here for more pictures

From DailyRecord.com’s Meghan Dyk:

The ambulance that burst into flames at the Flanders fire and rescue building this morning was the same one that sparked a new law extending the state’s “Lemon Law”’ provisions to emergency vehicles, officials said.

Photo by DailyRecord.com's Bob Karp.

Photos by DailyRecord.com's Bob Karp.

The ambulance, one of the three rigs operated by the Flanders First Aid and Rescue Squad, had just returned from a medical call before it was parked inside the fire house garage at 27 Main St. — then erupted in flames at 10:40 a.m., according to Jeff Paul, spokesman for the Morris County Prosecutor’s Office.

No one was inside at the time of the fire, but two firefighters from Flanders suffered smoke inhalation battling the flames.

Fire crews from Flanders, Budd Lake and Chester responded to the blaze within minutes after a smoke alarm inside the fire house was activated. The fire was knocked out quickly, said Doug Fenichel, spokesman for the Flanders Fire Department.

Melissa Hackenberg, 22, who lives behind the fire house on Railroad Avenue, said she saw the flames and grabbed a camera and began taking photos of the burning ambulance.

“All I saw was smoke billowing out of the fire house,” Hackenberg said. “I just couldn’t believe the firehouse was on fire. The flames were high, but never shot out of the firehouse. ”

The ambulance, after returning from the medical call, was placed out of service for an issue with its anti-lock braking system and an investigation revealed the fire originated in the area of the ABS within the engine compartment, Paul said.

The rig as a history of electrical issues, according to Mayor David Scapicchio. NJ Mt Olive lemon ambulance burns

“It was the lemon,” Scapicchio said, referring to the burned ambulance, after he visited the scene. “It is a shame, but we have insurance.”

After the then-new Ford ambulance broke down on a medical call three years ago, the Flanders first aid squad lobbied to include emergency vehicles in the state’s “Lemon Law,” which requires manufacturers and “component suppliers” of new vehicles to correct defects that are originally covered under the manufacturer’s warranty.

The law, which was signed earlier this month, applies to new vehicles that develop repeated defects or are unusable for extended periods during the first two years or within the first 18,000 miles of use.

A vehicle is considered a “lemon” if three repair attempts fail to correct the problem.

Quick Takes

1 comment

Fireground audio from mayday during fatal Randolph, NJ house fire: An elderly woman died and a firefighter was injured trying to get to her on the second floor in the fire late yesterday morning. According to DailyRecord.com’s Rob Jennings, “Randolph Fire Chief William Wagner said one firefighter suffered minor injuries after escaping a flashover on the second floor by tumbling head-first down a ladder to the ground.” Click here for the fireground audio (courtesy FireSceneAudio.com). There is more video here and here.

Join the STATter911.com Facebook fan page

Look over here for our player with the latest STATter911.com videos    >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Firing of top PGFD official has union president coming out swinging in message to members: If you are one of those who follows the Prince George’s County Fire/EMS Department closely you will want to read this. The ouster of Lt. Col. Victor Stagnaro (our sources say he was flat out fired, while Chief Eugene Jones says Stagnaro announced his intent to retire) has inspired a very direct message from Local 1619’s Andrew Pantelis to his members. It outlines rather complete dissatisfaction with the current department leadership. Here’s one quote: “… we now find it difficult to work in ‘good faith’ with an administration that clearly has no interest in respecting and upholding the rights that are guaranteed to the members that we serve”. The union president said it wasn’t meant as a press release when we asked him about it last night, but members and others sent a number of copies  our way. Click here to read the whole message.

That's Rebecca Knerr between Michelle Obama and Jill Biden. Her husband Joe returns from Haiti today with Virginia Task Force 1. An AP photo by Pablo Martinez Monsivais.

That's Rebecca Knerr between Michelle Obama and Jill Biden. Her husband Joe returns from Haiti today with Virginia Task Force 1. An AP photo by Pablo Martinez Monsivais.

Virginia Task Force 1 home today: Two weeks to the day after making their first of  16 rescues in Haiti, members of the first USAR team on the ground in Port-au-Prince after the earthquake are scheduled to return home. They should be back at the Fairfax County Fire & Rescue Department Training Academy late this afternoon. Last night, the wife of Capt. Joe Knerr, Rebecca (who is a former firefighter/paramedic in Fairfax County), was invited to sit with First Lady Michelle Obama during the State of the Union address. Click here for our interview with Joe Knerr last week from Haiti.

Also, click here for the latest rescue from Haiti. A 16-year-old girl pulled from the rubble 15 days after the earthquake

Washington City Paper's Darrow Montgomery's photo of ambulance and fire engine that caused so much controversy in the Nation's Capital.

Washington City Paper's Darrow Montgomery's photo of ambulance and fire engine that caused so much controversy in the Nation's Capital.

Not one, but two reports on DC’s ill-fated fire engine & ambulance donation to the Dominican Republic: Remember that contentious DC City Council hearing we showed you back in March of last year (I know, which one?) where Council member Phil Mendelson was trying to get to the bottom of a surplus fire engine and ambulance donation to the resort town of Sosua as he grilled Chief Dennis Rubin? (Click here, if you forgot.) The City Council has now issued two reports on the subject. Click here for the report by the Committe for Public Safety & the Judiciary and here for the report by the Committee for Government Operations & the Environment. Also, check out summaries by Mike DeBonis in the Washington City Paper and  Tim Craig in The Washington Post. And if that is not enough reading, just click here and scroll down to see all of our previous coverage on this one.

Truly a sad, sad, story: This is as tragic a set of circumstances that I have seen in a while. A New Jersey ambulance crew member returning from the hospital hears a fire call dispatched for his own home. His elderly father is inside the house. Even though Joseph Sims Jr.  isn’t apparently authorized to respond to that call, he does (how many of you wouldn’t?). While on the way, the ambulance collides with a car sending a woman to a trauma center. Sims’ father died in the house fire. Click here for more.

Another tragic story: Teenaged members of a volunteer fire department in Pennsylvania were apparently on the way to a department meeting and didn’t make it. Three bodies were found in the icy lake where their vehicle crashed. The Zelienople VFD is in mourning. Click here and here for coverage.

Must see video from the gas explosion in Belgium: The collapse of an apartment building hours after a gas explosion was caught on video. Click here to see it. But there is a lot more to the story, including the rescue of a young girl from the rubble. Firegeezer has the update.

Fireground audio from Buffalo third-alarm: Four buildings were destroyed in the fire yesterday morning. Click here for our coverage.

More from Singapore: Anyone who was intrigued by our video from a commercial fire in Singapore that we posted yesterday, will want to check this out. A long time reader, Deputy Chief P.J. Norwood from East Haven, Connecticut, spent some time teaching at the Singapore Civil Defense Force training academy and has some pictures on his Fire Engineering page.

Firing of top PGFD official brings scathing message from union president to his members. Local 1619’s Pantelis says ‘we now find it difficult to work in good faith’ with the department leadership.

31 comments
Lt. Col. Victor Stagnaro from PGFD website.

Lt. Col. Victor Stagnaro from PGFD website.

Click here for our previous coverage

Monday’s sudden firing of Lt. Col. Victor Stagnaro of the Prince George’s County Fire/EMS Department has brought out a lot of emotion. Just check out the more than 60 comments we have received.

The longest and what may be the most scathing reaction has now been sent our way. It didn’t come through the comments section. It was passed along via members of IAFF Local 1619 who received the email on Wednesday from their president, Andrew Pantelis.

It makes very clear the union’s dissatisfaction with the administration of Chief Eugene Jones. Rather than to characterize it any more than that, we have reprinted, below, it in its entirety.

Contacted this evening, Pantelis told STATter911.com, “This was not a press release. This was an internal communications to our members discussing the department’s state of affairs and the relationship between the Prince George’s County Fire/EMS Department and Local 1619″.

PGFD Chief Spokesman Mark Brady confirmed that Chief Jones was aware of the message sent to Local 1619’s members, but has no reaction to it at this time.

Through Brady, the chief provided a comment on Monday saying, “Colonel Stagnaro has indicated this afternoon his intent to retire from the fire and EMS department in the next two weeks” and will be on leave until that date.  Despite that, numerous sources familiar with what happened continue to tell us that Chief Jones’ executive officer presented  Stagnaro with a letter late Monday afternoon saying his services would not be needed as of February 12.

Here’s the communications between Andrew Pantelis and members of IAFF Local 1619:

MD PG Pantelis

Brothers and Sisters,

The Union has sat silently for some time regarding the Fire & EMS Department’s current state of affairs.  We have a responsibility to not respond to every rumor or half truth and to work with management to resolve disputes amicably.  However, the increased frequency of Departmental misinformation and recent actions demand a response.  The Union leadership came into office with an open mind and has made attempts to mend the relationship between the Union and the Department. However, we now find it difficult to work in “good faith” with an administration that clearly has no interest in respecting and upholding
the rights that are guaranteed to the members that we serve.

As many of you are now probably aware, on Monday January 25th, the Fire
Chief terminated Lieutenant Colonel Victor Stagnaro from the Prince
George’s County Fire & EMS Department.  It is the Union’s belief that
this action is not only unjustified but is a great disservice to our
members, to the Department, and to the citizens of Prince George’s
County.  Many of you may hear that Colonel Stagnaro’s termination was
the result of a grievance that was filed by the Union.  The unfortunate
fact is that the Fire Chief has used a grievance as a convenient excuse
to take an action that he has longed to execute for some time.

This Fire Department Administration has continuously demonstrated acts
of manipulation, disorganization, and failed leadership.  The Chief
frequently issues orders to subordinates that are either impossible to
carry out, a violation of the law, or dangerous to our members and the
citizens of the County.  When such orders place the Department in a
situation of embarrassment or liability, the Chief claims that he knew
nothing of what was occurring, that his command staff is working against
him, and claims no responsibility of his own.  Finally, when there is no
one left to blame, he turns against the Union.

For every grievance that the Union files, the Department takes an
alternative adverse action against our members.  Members of the command
staff spread the message that our current state of affairs is due to the
Union’s unwillingness to work with the Department.  That if we would
just trust the Fire Chief’s vision and give a little on some of our
protected rights and privileges that the Department would ultimately be
better off.   However, each time the Union attempts to work with the
Department in good faith, the leadership takes advantage of the
situation through manipulation and dishonesty.  This Union will give no
more; our members have already lost enough.

A common management tactic is to try and turn the Union membership
against the Union leadership.  Command Staff members float rumors about
the Union’s involvement in matters ranging from acting pay to promotions
to medic unit staffing.  They try to enrage our members with statements
such as the Department wants to make promotions easier but the Union
won’t let them.   That the Department wants to fully staff fire
apparatus but cannot do so because the Union will not relinquish the
medic unit staffing that is protected in the contract.  When the Union
demands that our members receive acting pay when they are placed in the
capacity of a different rank; the Department initiates massive transfers
and claims that the Union demanded such transfers occur.

The Fire Department management is clearly giving the Union more credit
than we deserve.  If the Union had the power to make the aforementioned
items occur, we would have a professional development plan with training
requirements that were relevant for the each job description and such
training would be provided to members while on duty.  If the Union
controlled the Department staffing, redeployments and rotating closures
would be eliminated and our members wouldn’t still be going into burning
buildings alone on the line.  And if the Union had the ability to
control Departmental transfers, we would start where the greatest
problem of all is: at the Largo Government Center.

To the members of the command staff who still work in the best interest
of our employees and the Department, we commend you for your efforts.
Doing the right thing isn’t always the most popular or the easiest and
you often take great risks trying to do what is right for our members.

To those who are against us, we have a message for you.  We will not
waiver in our obligation to protect our members’ safety and contractual
rights.  We will utilize every legal and financial mechanism at our
disposal to ensure that our members are protected.  We will expose those
who hide in the shadows and work against us.

Effective immediately, every contractual benefit or prevailing right
that is violated will be immediately addressed through the official
grievance process.  We will no longer give the Department the benefit of
the doubt and afford them opportunities to correct “mistakes” that are
clear violations of our rights.  Our members continue to do more with
less and we will do everything within our power to protect what little
we have left.

We ask that you all remain strong during these trying times.  Be certain
that additional challenges still lie ahead.  However, we will weather
this storm and ultimately emerge stronger than ever.

Fraternally,

Andrew Pantelis
President

Police chief says New Jersey ambulance driver was not on a legal response when he went to a fire in his own house. Ambulance crashed. Father died in fire.

8 comments

Watch the story from WMGM-TV

This is an update to a tragic story from New Jersey I first saw on FirefighterCloseCalls.com earlier today.  It is about Joseph Sims Jr., who was driving an ambulance back from the hospital when he became aware that the home he shared with his father, also Joseph Sims, was on fire.

While responding in the ambulance to the burning home there was a serious collision with another vehicle. Sims and his partner in the unit were not seriously hurt, but a 43-year-old woman was airlifted to a trauma center. The reports are her condition has stabilized.

Joseph Sims died in the fire in the Erma Section of Lower Township. As you will see in the excerpts from this Press of Atlantic City article, the response by the ambulance to the house fire is not considered legal:

Police say the Middle Township ambulance driver who crashed into another vehicle Tuesday while responding to a fire that killed his father, was not responding in an official capacity.

Joseph Sims, Jr., a member of the Middle Township Ambulance Corps, raced to the scene after finding out about the fire — but the ambulance collided with a Chevy Trailblazer driven by Alyn Toth, 43, of Burleigh section of Middle Township.

Middle Township Police Chief Christopher Leusner said Sims would not have been able to legally respond to the Lower Township fire.

Collapse zone: The must see video from Belgium after a gas explosion at an apartment building.

No comments

More from Firegeezer.com

Two STATter911.com readers alerted us to this video from Liege, Belgium (but Statter wasn’t alert enough to get it on the blog a little faster). The collapse occurred about five hours after the intial explosion gutted much of the building. Below are details from the AP:

A five-story apartment building caught fire and collapsed Wednesday after an apparent gas explosion, injuring at least 21 people, including a teenager who was pulled from the rubble, officials said.

The blast occurred at about 2 a.m. (0100 GMT) and as darkness fell Wednesday night firefighters were still digging through the rubble looking for other survivors since two separate voices had been heard from within the wreckage, officials said.

Smoke and small fires were making the search difficult, especially for the sniffer dogs being used. Bricks and twisted metal remained piled piled yards (meters) high.

Belgian King Albert II visited the site to show his support for the rescue workers and his sympathy for the victims, including the teenage girl who had been rescued from the wreckage.

“It is likely there was a gas explosion,” Liege Mayor Willy Demeyer said. There had been a gas alert in the building over the weekend, but no leak was discovered, he said.

Immediately after the blast, a fire raged through the building and thick smoke billowed into the air. The blast shattered windows in nearby City Hall and spread debris and dust throughout the adjacent streets in downtown Liege.

“It was such a noise that we thought the explosion happened inside City Hall, even though the actual explosion was more than one hundred meters (yards) away, so the whole neighborhood was woken up and devastated,” said Demeyer. Most of the historic center of the city was closed because of the explosion.

The 21 people reported injured were more than the dozen residents who officially lived in the building. But the apartments often house university students who may have had guests sleeping over when the blast occurred.

Fireground audio, video & pictures from 3-alarm Buffalo fire. Four buildings destroyed.

2 comments

Click here for slideshow from fire

From Collin Bishop, WGRZ-TV:

Buffalo Firefighters were busy overnight battling a massive fire on the west side.

NY Buffalo fireAt least four buildings were destroyed, including an apartment complex and a business in the 200 block of Auburn.

The call came in around 12:30 a.m.

Witnesses say you could see smoke and flames from miles away.

Firefighters say there were no injuries reported, but there is extensive damage.

The cause of the fire is still under investigation, but firefighters believe it started in the commercial building.

So many firefighters responded to the fire that additional firefighters had to be called in overnight to make sure the city was covered in the event of a second fire.

Auburn Avenue is closed between Grant and Parkdale this morning because of all the fire equipment still on the scene.

Click here for Part 2 of the audio.

Quick Takes

4 comments

How they do it in Singapore: Good quality, close-up video of the fire department in Singapore in action late last Thursday morning at a commercial fire. Here’s part of the description - 3 Fire Engines, 2 Firebikes, 3 Red Rhinos, 3 Supporting Vehicles, 1 Ambulance were immediately dispatched to the incident site. Upon arrival, fire was found raging from the two-storey shop house. SCDF firefighters immediately set up water jets and pitched ladder to gain access into the shophouse. As the fire had partially burnt through the roof, water jets were used to tackle the fire from the top. Here’s the Street View of the building on Moonstone Lane and the surrounding neighborhood (look at the business and the clutter across the street). Watch more from the Official Singapore Civil Defense Force Videos on YouTube.

Radio traffic after firefighter struck: Firefighter Cory Broich, father of five, is in the hospital with two broken legs. The woman driving the car that hit Broich and the fire engine was also hurt. Listen to the incident from Clearwater, Minnesota and read the details.

Fireground audio from close call in Virginia: If you haven’t checked in with us since early yesterday morning the fire on Heming Avenue turned out to be a double fatal. The bodies of two men were found inside. Three firefighters from Fairfax County found the kitchen floor crumbling around them and needed help getting out. One firefighter was slightly hurt. We have the radio traffic and raw video. Click here.

Virginia Task Force 1 scheduled to return: As of yesterday’s briefing the USAR team from Northern Virginia is expected to fly to the Dominican Republic today and then back to the Washington area on Thursday. They have been in Haiti for two weeks.

More on shake-up in Prince George’s County: Mark Brady’s PGFD PIO blog takes a closer look at the 24-year-career of Lt. Col. Victor Stagnaro who was suddenly dismissed via a letter from the Chief Eugene Jones on Monday (the chief says Colonel Stagnaro expressed his intent to retire after 24-years). The comments section here is burning up on this issue and was by far our most read story over the last 36 hours.

The director speaks: Memphis Fire Department Director Alvin Benson finally talks to the reporter who has been featuring a rather unflattering side of his department in reports over the last 8 days or so. Click here for the latest.

Brownouts in San Diego: They start next week as a budget saving measure. Read more.

And what will it sound like if they win the Super Bowl?: We were sent a recording of the New Orleans Fire Department’s radio traffic immediately after the Saints won Sunday night. Check it out.

Officials have more to say about new volunteer accused of setting fires: We had previously told you about 24-year-old Adam Paul Carriere who was accused of starting two fires within days of joining a fire department in the Baton Rouge area. A press conference is scheduled for this afternoon where investigators are expected to point out that Mr. Carriere was a bit more prolific than originally thought. Here’s the story.

Firefighter hurt as two are grabbed from Alaska house fire: The woman was on the phone with 911 screaming shortly before firefighters pulled up to the Anchorage home. There’s a lot of detail in the article on how the firefighters got the woman and a man out yesterday morning. One firefighter cut up his foot on window glass. Click here.

Saved from the mighty Mississippi a woman says thanks in a big way: Kay Dickison knows it was a 911 call taker and firefighters who saved her after falling through the ice trying to rescue her dog on the Mississippi River in Dakota County, Minnesota last month. She didn’t just say thanks. She wrote a check for $2500 so firefighters can get additional cold-water suits. Click here for the story.

Dissension in Vermont: A volunteer firefighter in Wallingford says he was blindsided by his dismissal after bringing up concerns about safety and how the fire department is run. The board of directors says he didn’t follow the chain of command with his complaints.  Here are the details.

Radio traffic after firefighter struck on I-94 in Minnesota. Clearwater Fire & Rescue’s Cory Broich recovering from injuries.

2 comments

Clearwater Fire & Rescue

FirefighterCloseCalls.com

Article by Karie Petrie, St. Cloud Times:

A Clearwater firefighter responding to a vehicle fire on Interstate Highway 94 was struck by a vehicle Tuesday morning.

Minnesota State Patrol photo.

Minnesota State Patrol photo.

The eastbound lanes of the interstate were closed for nearly three hours.

The collision happened at 7:17 a.m. west of Clearwater. A vehicle traveling east hit 28-year-old Cory Broich and a Clearwater fire truck, according to the State Patrol.

Broich was airlifted to St. Cloud Hospital in critical condition.

The driver of the striking vehicle was Deborah A. Symalla, 43, of Cold Spring. She was taken to St. Cloud Hospital where she was treated and released, according to the patrol.

The interstate was closed shortly after the crash and reopened shortly before 11 a.m. 

Firefighter Cory Broich.

Firefighter Cory Broich.

Clearwater Fire Chief Doug Nieters said Broich, of Clearwater, has been a firefighter for five years. Nieters said the fire crew was finishing up with the vehicle fire call when the crash occurred.

The fire department had two fire trucks on scene when Broich was hit. Another fire truck was brought to the scene after the collision.

Ashly Madson is Broich’s sister-in-law. She said Broich and his wife Abigail have five children under the age of 8.

Madson said Broich has broken both legs, but did not suffer a head injury. He is awake and talking to his wife, she said.

“He’s doing as well as he can be,” she said.

Saints and sinners: Fire Department radio traffic after New Orleans became Super Bowl bound.

14 comments

A little break from all of the gloom and doom you get on STATter911.com. This is NOFD radio traffic immediately after the Saints defeated the Vikings Sunday night. We have compressed the time a little bit and took out some of the dead air. It ends just after the first medical call was dispatched for an apparent injured celebrant.

Fireground audio & raw video from close call at double fatal Fairfax County house fire. One injury to firefighter after floor collapse.

8 comments

Click here for slideshow from the fatal fire

Fairfax County Fire & Rescue Department PIO Dan Schmidt confirms the bodies of two men were found inside a burning home on Heming Avenue in North Springfield this morning. The fire was reported around 6:40 AM. First arriving firefighters found fire in the basement with two residents not accounted for.

Schmidt tells STATter911.com that in the early stages of the fire, firefighters from Engine 422 ran into trouble when the kitchen floor began collapsing around them. The crew apparently became separated by the hole(s) in the floor. Other firefighters assisted them in getting out safely. Schmidt says one firefighter has been hospitalized with non-life threatening injuries.

Officials aren’t yet saying where in the home the bodies were found.

Quick Takes

1 comment

House explodes and burns in Cleveland: A neighbor’s video as three people were hurt after an explosion at West 83rd Street and Madison Avenue. Click here for more details and videos.

Become a fan of  STATter911.com on Facebook

Watch our latest videos over here    >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

UPDATED – Close call in Fairfax County, VA at scene of now double fatal fire: (Click here for slideshow from fire.) PIO Dan Schmidt confirms the bodies of two men were found inside a burning home on Heming Avenue in North Springfield this morning. Earlier three firefighters from Station 422 ran into trouble when the kitchen floor began collapsing around them. Other firefighters assisted them in getting out safely. Schmidt says one firefighter has been hospitalized with non-life threatening injuries.  All firefighters were accounted for. The fire was reported around 6:40 AM. We will have more later, including video.

Dead, not dead: Firefighters in Prince George’s County, Maryland thought they were doing body recovery early Sunday morning on I-95. The “body” in the burned out car started breathing and things quickly reverted to a rescue operation. We have the details, fireground audio, and a timeline. Click here for our coverage.

More PGFD news – Shake-up at the top: In November, Chief Eugene Jones said about Lt. Colonel Victor Stagnaro, “You are growing into the leader I always believed you had the capacity for” as he gave the 24-year veteran “a rare and prestigious” department award. Yesterday, Chief Jones gave Stagnaro something else: his walking papers. According to Chief Jones, Stagnaro “indicated his intent to retire”. But numerous other sources familiar with what happened at the Largo Government Center tell STATter911.com the chief’s executive officer presented Stagnaro with a letter telling him his last day is February 12. Click here for more on this story.

Close Call #1: This is the "before" picture a neighbor snapped just prior to two firefighters falling through the roof of this burning Phoenix home on Monday. The firefighters were not injured. Police say the house was set on fire by an 18-year-old who had assaulted his parents. Click the image to see more pictures and watch the story.

Close Call #1: This is the "before" picture a neighbor snapped just prior to two firefighters falling through the roof of this burning Phoenix home on Monday. The firefighters were not injured. Police say the house was set on fire by an 18-year-old who had assaulted his parents. Click the image to see more pictures and watch the story.

Two Metro workers killed on tracks in Maryland: Montgomery County firefighters were busy early this morning when two employees of Metro were struck and killed by a hi-rail vehicle on the rail system’s Red Line in the Rockville area around 1:55 this morning. Read the story here. Click here for the video. Click here for pictures.

NEW – Virginia Task Force 1 heading home Thursday: That’s the plan today for the return of the urban search and rescue team from Northern Virginia. They have been in Haiti for two weeks and are now assisting with humanitarian efforts after helping to rescue 16 people who were trapped in the rubble of the earthquake.

Other teams are already home.  Click here for video from the return of the Miami-Dade team.

Firegeezer also has some return videos for teams from Virginia, New York and the UK.

More from Memphis: A TV station is into its second week of reports on the Memphis Fire Department. WLMT-TV has been looking at the department’s hiring practices, the number of firefighters who have been arrested and allegations of discrimination over who gets to keep their job and who doesn’t. The latest installment is here. Click here to see what you missed earlier.

Four fire officers on leave as fatal house fire is probed in Georgia: Firefighters in DeKalb County were sent to a 911 disconnect at 1:00 Sunday morning. A fire truck was sent to investigate. The firefighters found nothing. Five hours later the house was destroyed with a woman inside. Read and watch the story. Read DeKalb County public safety director’s statement.

New talk of major FDNY cuts: Firehouses and firefighters are again being discussed for possible cuts as mayor’s staff and the new fire commissioner meet on budget issues. Read more.

911 system in DC getting scrutiny after gun is pulled on council member: A fire truck was the first on the scene to assist Council member Yvette Alexander last week when she interupted an armed robbery. There are questions about the accurate relay of information and the timeliness of the response. Read more.

Three firefighters inside as explosion lifts roof off home during fire in Wells, Minnesota. The chief says he was blown 3-feet out of a door. The firefighters weren't hurt. Click the picture by Brie Cohen for details and more pictures from the Albert Lea Tribune.

Close Call #2: Three firefighters inside as explosion lifts roof off home during fire in Wells, Minnesota. The chief says he was blown 3-feet out of a door. The firefighters weren't hurt. Click the picture by Brie Cohen for details and more pictures from the Albert Lea Tribune.

Former Columbus, Ohio firefighter who killed dogs walks out of hearing because of TV camera: The latest on David Santuomo, who left the two dead dogs in a dumpster behind a firehouse in December, 2008, is that the Civil Service Commission dismissed the appeal of his firing because the former firefighter wasn’t present. News reports indicate Santuomo got up and left when he saw the camera being set up. You may recall Santuomo executed the dogs because he didn’t want to pay kennel fees while on vacation. Read more.

LAFD defends dog rescue: The Los Angeles Fire Department stands by the decision to commit resources to last Friday’s dog rescue in the L.A. River that left a firefighter with dog bites. Read more. Earlier coverage here and here.

Mayor is shocked: Paramus, New Jersey Mayor James Tedesco is also a volunteer firefighter. Responding on a call for a downed power line, the firefighting mayor touched a fence that had come in contact with the wire. He is okay. Read more.

House fire in New Jersey: This is from yesterday in Oradell in Bergen County.

Prince George’s County firefighters get a surprise during body recovery at I-95 crash scene. Review underway into why breathing man was declared dead. Listen to radio traffic.

32 comments

 

Read entire PGFD statement from Chief Spokesman Mark Brady

A 26-year-old man trapped inside his burning Cadillac that had run into the back of another vehicle on I-95 in Laurel is being treated for critical injuries despite initially being declared dead on the scene. STATter911.com has learned firefighters from Prince George’s County, Maryland discovered the man was breathing while untangling his body from the wreckage of the burned out car. The vehicle had slammed against trees in the median strip near Route 198.

When Prince George’s County firefighters extinguished the fire around 2:30 Sunday morning the man was declared a “Priority 4″. Prince George’s County Fire/EMS Department Chief Spokesman Mark Brady confirms this in a statement provided to STATter911.com, saying, “A preliminary patient assessment was made soon after the fire was extinguished, while the victim was still trapped within the wreckage, that he was priority 4 (deceased).”

On the emergency radio traffic from the incident, the  incident commander tells a dispatcher about the “Priority 4″ at 2:39 AM, 25 minutes after the incident was dispatced and 16 minutes after the first firefighters arrived on the scene.

Brady also confirms at 2:47 AM firefighters were asked by Maryland State Police to help in the removal of the body. About a minute later firefighters determined the man was still breathing.

In the radio traffic from the incident, a firefighter and the “South Side Command” have the following conversation:

Unidentified Firefighter:  “We believe the patient is breathing we are yanking him out and bringing him up.”

South Side Command: “You say the patient is breathing?”

Unidentified Firefighter: “We believe so.”

South Side Command: “Okay.”

The injured man, whose identity has not been released, was removed from the car and taken to a burn unit under the care of paramedics. At last word from police, he was being treated for life-threatening burns and other injuries.

Spokesman Brady confirms that a review  is underway by the department’s EMS Quality Assurance and Quality Improvement Program to determine what procedures were used to initially determine the man had expired. Brady said in his statement, “The Q&A program provides both a forum for continuous system improvement and a means to review significant events and is implemented under the auspices of the EMS Jurisdictional Program Medical Director.”

Brady also points out, “The preliminary patient assessment was made under extremely challenging and less then ideal conditions.”

A second vehicle involved in the crash was handled by a separate “North Side Command”. Firefighters removed a woman who was trapped in an overturned SUV that had been struck by the Cadillac. That vehicle was not on fire. Police report the 46-year-old woman was treated and released at a local hospital.

Here is a timeline of the incident based on information provided by PGFD and times listed in the radio traffic:

2:14 – Call dispatched.

2:23 – First PGFD units report on the scene.

2:39 – South Side Command reports they have a “Priority 4″.

2:47 – South Side Command reports they have been requested by Maryland State Police to extricate “the deceased”.

2:48 - Firefighters report they believe the patient is breathing.

2:49 – Medic 715 from Montgomery County is dispatched to assist with the now breathing patient.

2:56 – Landing site being set up for helicopter.

3:04 – Patient transported by ground to burn unit.