Skip to content


Four DeKalb County, Georgia firefighters fired over response to fire. Elderly woman dead after crews didn’t find burning house during initial response.

6 comments

More from AJC.com

More from The Secret List

Read DeKalb County report into fire response

From the AP:

Four firefighters were terminated Thursday and they are being investigated by police for their response to a house fire that killed an elderly woman.

The DeKalb County firefighters responded to a 911 call from the home about 1 a.m. Sunday and left after they didn’t see any signs of flames or smoke.

But according to an investigative report, they didn’t follow department procedure to approach the home, verify the address and make contact with the 911 caller. 

Ann Bartlett in a family photo.

Ann Bartlett in a family photo.

Most of the firefighters who responded to the call stayed in their vehicles, only getting out to help the trucks turn around in the cul-de-sac near the home, according to the report.

About six hours later, a neighbor called 911 to report the same house was fully engulfed in flames. Ann Bartlett, 74, was found dead inside from smoke inhalation.

“These officers didn’t follow policy, and that’s why they’re being terminated,” county public safety director William Z. Miller said Friday.

Police in Dunwoody, a northern Atlanta suburb, have launched a criminal investigation into the fire department’s response, police Chief Billy Grogan said.

The four firefighters are acting officer in charge William Greene, Capt. Tony L. Motes, Battalion Chief Lesley Clark and Battalion Chief Bennie J. Paige. A fifth firefighter, Capt. Sell Caldwell, has been put on leave with pay as an investigation into his actions continues, DeKalb County spokeswoman Shelia Edwards said.

Paige did not immediately return a call for comment Friday. There were no public phone listings for the rest of the firefighters and it was not known if they had retained attorneys.

Bartlett’s daughter, Ruth, said Friday she hopes “every firefighter learns from this.” She said her family wants an apology from the firefighters.

“We know those four men feel awful,” she said in a telephone interview. “First, we were very shocked. Then we were very sad, and as the facts started to unravel, we became mad. Now as we see they are resolving and taking actions they deem appropriate, we are starting to heal.”

Also on STATter911 …

Comments

Powered by Facebook Comments

6 Comments

  1. Steve says

    Really?? You get a report of a dwelling fire and just cruise around the block without stopping at the address to look in a window or knock on the front door? Makes you wonder how many times they’ve pulled this stunt before without getting burned. You know, The City of Dunwoody incorporated in 2008 and started its own police department but decided to stick with the County Fire Department. Maybe its time for them to start their own independent City of Dunwoody Fire Department like all those cities in North Fulton County did. Time to break away from the corrupt and incompetent county government. DeKalb doesn’t sound much better than Fulton. What a joke.

    on January 30, 2010 @ 11:54 am. Reply
  2. Danny H. says

    There is some hope still alive. Appears there may be Criminal Charges involved!!1

    on January 30, 2010 @ 8:20 pm. Reply
  3. FitSsikS says

    As firefighters we know some things are beyond our control.

    For example, this 1 mile (as the crow flys) run turns into almost 2 1/2 miles on the meandering streets that make up this neighborhood.

    Also, Mrs Bartlett may have misunderstood “Evacuate the house!” indicated by her reply, “Yes it’s a house.”

    As I said, those are factors ffs can’t control.

    However fire dept staff are responsible for their actions at every call.

    …or lack thereof.

    :(

    My condolences to Mrs Bartlett’s family.

    on January 31, 2010 @ 10:15 am. Reply

Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.

Continuing the Discussion

  1. Different Approach = Different Outcome | Firegeezer linked to this post

    [...] We have been following the sad outcome in DeKalb County (HERE). Dave Statter provides the latest update (HERE). [...]

    on January 31, 2010 @ 1:41 pm.
  2. Tweets that mention Four DeKalb County, Georgia firefighters fired over response to fire. Elderly woman dead after crews didn’t find burning house during initial response. | STATter911.com -- Topsy.com linked to this post

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Dave Statter, Dave Statter and Eric Steinberg, Eric Steinberg. Eric Steinberg said: RT @STATter911: 4 DeKalb Co., GA firefighters let go after fatal house #fire response. http://tinyurl.com/yz8bp3f #firefighter #firefigh … [...]

    on January 31, 2010 @ 10:18 pm.
  3. Accountability: Errors & Omissions | The Company Officer linked to this post

    [...] This past week on the burgeoning internet call-in radio show Firefighter Netcast.com, HERE, a dynamic discussion developed related to the DeKalb County fatal house fire incident and the apparent questionable (lack) of actions purported by the company and command officers and the repercussions that have lead to FD employment terminations and resignations, HERE. [...]

    on February 5, 2010 @ 9:16 am.