Skip to content


What you liked in 2009. The most popular stories of last year from STATter911.com. Plus, our contest winner.

12 comments

We have a winner! The very first entry into our top stories contest for 2009 correctly guessed the top story of the year. Even though the rest of that person’s top five weren’t on target, it gave me hope for you people and this contest. Once again, Statter was wrong.

Many of you were blinded by our extensive coverage of PGFD and one man in particular, who at last look was still in the Prince George’s County Detention Center. You will have to scroll way done to number 14 to find his picture on this page. Other entries, including one from a person who should know better, focused way too much on our coverage of the District of Columbia Fire & EMS Department. Only one DC story made the list (but it was a big one at number two).  In fact, only eight of the top 20 were local stories from the Washington, DC area. Remember that for next year’s contest. We are global in scope here at STATter911.com (yeah, right!).

To get a winner we had to go deep down to someone who guessed two of the top five. While he had the two top stories in reverse order, author and fire service veteran from Baltimore County Chris Hawley was the only entrant to get more than one out of five. The good news is the two Baltimore boys should have lots to talk about when this one buys lunch.

Our rankings are based on the number of pageviews between January 1 and December 31, 2009 according to Google Analytics. If a story had multiple postings we only counted the top one for our list.

The interesting thing is that the bottom two stories and the 21st story were just nine clicks apart. Their rankings kept changing up until the closing hours of 2009. In the end, a somewhat odd, but newer story from Montgomery County, Maryland moved up, knocking off one of my personal favorites from earlier in the year. Number 21 is the story of Alexandria Fire Department (VA) veteran Doug Townshend who, while off duty, rescued his brother Mike from a burning home. Click here for that story.

Click the Popeye cartoon to see what used to pass for a year-end review at STATter911.com.

Click the Popeye cartoon to see what used to pass for a year-end review at STATter911.com.

By the way, I did this type of year end review, rather than the more humorous (at least I thought so) version of the two previous years, because I thought it would be easier to manage. I am writing this at 4:00 AM on New Years Day, so now I am not so sure. If you miss the old one, here it is (I am sure most of it is still true today anyway).

Obviously isn’t just us taking a look back at 2009 and ahead to 2010. Other fire service sites beat us to the punch. Paul Peluso at Firehouse.com says 2009 was the year of the video (look below for proof). FireRescue1.com has a host of characters writing lots of words under its year in review banner. Billy Goldfeder has a message for the new year at FirefighterCloseCalls.com. Paul Combs has a great thought in his December cartoon at FireEngineering.com. I am sure Bill Schumm will have something to help bring in the new year Firegeezer style and so will many others who share the FireEMSBlogs.com site with this rag. .

And Rhett Fleitz at The Fire Critic, who is a great inspiration and supporter to all of us who blog, has a contest that is better than mine. Rhett  is looking for the Fire/EMS Blog of the Year 2009 (now you know why I said those nice things about him). Rhett’s is better because he is promoting it as the contest with the prize where you don’t have to sit across the lunch table from Dave Statter.

Thank you to all who entered our contest. Thank you to all who read and comment each day. Thank you to all who link to STATter911.com and carry our stories. Most important, a happy and safe 2010 to all of you and especially those out there protecting us each and every day.

So, drum roll please! We present our 20 most popular stories from 2009:  

1. May 30 – Confrontation caught on video between Oklahoma State Highway Patrol Trooper Daniel Martin and Creek Nation Paramedic Maurice White Jr.

 

This was the story that dominated 2009 on STATter911.com. Not only did the posting on May 30  (our fourth posting on the topic) bring in 43 percent more pageviews than our number two story for the year, three other stories on the confrontation would have taken places two, three, and four. When you add up the clicks for the almost 20 stories we posted on this topic they account for about five-percent of the overall traffic on the blog for 2009.

There have been more than 700 comments (actually a lot more than that, but many we couldn’t publish). A couple of comments still arrive each week.

If you would like to see some of the other stories on this one, click here and keep scrolling.

I think the reason for the high numbers, besides being a hot topic, is that we apparently reached way beyond our normal fire and EMS service audience on this story. It helps that the YouTube video above, which has more than two million views, has our link in its description.

2. October 9 – District of Columbia Fire & EMS Department Sprinkler Demonstration mishap.

As much grief as I get for carrying too many negative stories on the blog, the only reason the world knew about this one is because I was trying to do a good deed and post some positive news. On Wednesday, October 7 there were two sprinkler demonstrations scheduled in the National Capital region. One at Gallaudet University and the other at the University of Maryland (at MFRI). My goal was to get to both of them, but the Maryland one was the priority because of the release of a study about Prince George’s County’s mandatory residential sprinkler law. I never made it to DC and no one said anything to me about a problem during that demonstration.

As I was about to leave work the following evening I was feeling guilty the DC sprinkler video didn’t get any play in my story the day before (there had been a photographer on the scene from LNS, the local news service run by my station and two others in Washington). I pulled the video up with the intention of editing something for the blog and possibly WUSA9.com. Of course, as I watched the video, I immediately realized there was a little bit more to this demonstration.

This entry had 128 comments. More comments came in after Chief Dennis Rubin, when talking about what he saw, used the term “comedy act”.

Click here to see our follow-up stories on the sprinkler demonstration.

3. December 17 – Flashover in Erwin, North Carolina.

Firefighter Will Gregory exits the home with his PPE on fire. Photo by Brian Haney, The Daily Record.

Firefighter Will Gregory exits the home with his PPE on fire. Photo by Brian Haney, The Daily Record.

This was a late entry for the year. It came about because FirefighterCloseCalls.com first put out the story of the close call based on the newspaper article by Brian Haney at The Daily Record in Dunn, NC. Figuring that there might be more than one photo, I called Mr. Haney and he told me he had shot 210 images from that fire. Brian sent a bunch to STATter911.com and gave us permission to use the photos.

4. January 9 – The crash of Boston Fire Department Ladder 26 killing Lt. Kevin M. Kelley.

Until a day or two ago, this was in the number three spot for the year. In my heart I wish it was number one. I was blogging away on the Friday afternoon that Ladder 26 wrecked trying to keep up with the developments from Boston. Later in the evening when we learned that Lt. Kevin Kelley was the firefighter killed, it didn’t take long to find his appearances from Firehouse USA on the web. How can you not smile when you watch these?

5. November 15 – Was that a leaf blower? Yes it was.

While I get a lot of stories and videos from your tips, this is one I found all by myself. Going through fire related YouTube videos on a Sunday evening I happened upon this clip. I usually don’t run controlled burning type training exercises, but this one looked different. After picking my jaw off the floor upon seeing the unusual PPV via the leaf blower, I decided this was one worthy of a wider audience.

6. February 3 - Cruise ship takes out DC fireboat.

You have to admit this one was different. The 160-foot Spirit of Washington squeezed the 72-foot John H. Glenn Jr., putting a big gash in the Glenn’s hull and sidelining the boat for many months. The collision also crushed a small FBI boat at an adjacent dock.  

7. September 11 - A rewarding save in Muskegon, Michigan.

MI Muskegon rescue

This is a rather simple story of a rescue in that it was popular despite there being no video of the event. Firefighters saving the day when it looks like that might be impossible.

 Here’s how WZZM-TV’s Lambrini Lukidis described the story:

Kelysse LaBelle is full of energy today. But when fireman Scott Campau rescued her from the bottom of Fisherman’s Landing in Muskegon last week, Kelysse was purple, her eyes were gray and lifeless.

“The stroller was actually sitting up-right on its wheels on the bottom of the lake and she was unconscious,” said Campau.

“She wasn’t breathing, no heart rate,” said Battalion Chief Ken Chudy who lead the team on the call. “She was lifeless when we pulled her out of the water,” said Fireman Kevin McMillan also assisted by firemen Chad Horn and Scott Hemmeslbach.

8. May 7 – Natural gas explosion injured 8 firefighters in Prince George’s County, Maryland.

Eight Prince George’s County firefighters were hurt when an explosion occurred while they were investigating a natural has leak at a shopping center in Forestville. 

9.  July 20 – Firefighter brothers from Milwaukee save child from burning car.

Truly one of the great stories of the year. John and Joel Rechlitz received national attention for their off-duty rescue of a young boy from a burning car. Their efforts didn’t stop after the rescue. The firefighters remained close to D.J. Harper and his family. Click here.

10. February 28 – Tower audio from plane crash at Denver airport.

CO-Denver-Continental-1404-724820

In December, 2008 Continental Flight 1404 ran off a runway and burst into flames at Denver International Airport. This was the audio as the airport tower controllers directed firefighters to the scene.

11. September 6 – Ladder collapses at Pennsylvania fire.

Photographer Wayne E. Ray captured the before and after pictures of New Eagle VFD’s Ladder 14 during a building fire in Monongahela, Pennsylvania.

12. August 24 – Lt. Charles “Chip” McCarthy & FF Jonathan Croom, Buffalo Fire Department.

NY-Buffalo-LODDs-724509

The fireground audio provided by Erie County Fire wire was very difficult to listen to as these two men responded to a call for help inside the burning building on Genesee Street.

13. April 29 – Flint firefighters say cutbacks delayed getting water on fatal fire.

MI-Flint-ftal-fire-777263

Layoffs and budget cuts were THE story of 2009. We saw a lot of stories like this one, but for some reason the Flint fire got more attention than the others.

14. May 6 – Former Prince George’s County volunteer firefighter Jerry Engle talks about possible arson ring involving firefighters.

MD-PG-Engle1

What more can I say about this frequent subject of STATter911.com stories. In the interview Jerry Engle told us all about an arson ring involving firefighters. Later in the year Engle and another former volunteer from Riverdale were both charged with the fire Jerry told us about. If you haven’t read enough about him, click here for our Jerry archive.

15. April 8 – Firefighter Daniel McGown burned in Prince George’s County house fire.

MD-PG-Largo-4-789110

PGFD’s Daniel McGown was rescued by fellow firefighters from this burning Largo home and is now back on the job.

16. January 16 – Prince William County dissolves Gainesville VFD.

VA-Prince-william--Gainesville-747467

After concerns over a long period of time the county moved in to make rather dramatic changes at a long time volunteer company. 

17. August 18 – The 50th anniversary of the BLEVE that killed five firefighters in Kansas City.

KMBC-720105

A touching tribute to firefighters who were lost 50-years earlier. The incident is believed to be the first time the term BLEVE was used to describe the rupture and rocketing of a flammable liquid container during a fire.

18. March 11 – Risk a lot to save a lot: A story from Tulsa.

OK-Tulsa-rescue-733246

It took teamwork and a lot of guts as a dispatcher and engine company worked to save a woman trapped in an apartment fire started thanks to a  neighbor’s meth lab. Video shows Chad Meyer from Engine 26 basically walking through fire to bring out Nikki Cain.  

19. December 1 – Firehouse sleepover becomes a waste management problem in Burtonsville, Maryland.

Burtonsville

This entry from Montgomery County had to be one of the more unusual stories of the year. A firefighter’s date spent the night at the firehouse and got lost on the way to the bathroom.

20. January 26, 2008 – Report into the April, 2007 death of Prince William County, Virginia’s Kyle Wilson.

VA-Prince-William-Wilson-764461Yes, you read the dates correctly.

What this means is that, even though Kyle Wilson died in a house fire in April, 2007 and the report was released nine-months later, firefighters are still interested in learning from this tragic situation. Enough people searched, found and apparently read that entry in 2009 to make it part of our top 20.

I think that’s a good sign.

DC union president takes issue with chief’s "comedy act" remarks. Rubin stands by his assessment of sprinkler demo that went went wrong.

23 comments
YouTube Preview Image

Above, raw video from out interview with Chief Dennis Rubin on the problems with the October 7 sprinkler demonstration at Gallaudet University where a firefighter was burned. President Raymond Sneed of IAFF Local 36 follows Chief Rubin with his thoughts about the incident.

Watch 9NEWS NOW 7:00 PM story

Previous coverage: Firefighter burned 10/9; Chief Rubin talks with Ed Comeau 10/12

DC Fire & EMS Department Chief Dennis Rubin’s explanation that he is responsible for the errors that left one firefighter with minor burns during a sprinkler demonstration at Gallaudet University does not sit well with the head of the firefighters’ union. President Raymond Sneed of IAFF Local 36 believes the chief taking the blame is not good enough and plans to present the issue to elected officials in the city. Sneed hopes they will review the performance of the fire chief and other top officials responsible for the demonstration.

Chief Rubin says he has learned a lesson and will not take things for granted in the future. Rubin echoed the remarks he made Monday during an interview for a fire service Internet podcast conducted by Ed Comeau. Comeau, with Campus-Firewatch.com, helped put on the October 7 demonstration.

Sneed’s biggest complaint is with the chief’s statement to Comeau that the mishap that brought burning plastic onto the gear of three firefighters and their efforts to extinguish it looked like a “comedy act”. “It still in my mind looked like a comedy act”, Chief Rubin said in a Tuesday interview with STATter911.com. “Firefighters to be fully involved and to not have a backup line. I am going to stand by that”.

Sneed said if the chief is sticking by that statement then “he’s the chief comedian because he staged it, he orchestrated it and he narrated it”. Sneed added, “One of my members was hospitalized from this comedy act”.

YouTube Preview Image

Video above is by Ed Comeau, Campus-Firewatch.com.

Asked about his thoughts as he watched the burning Plexiglas draft curtain from the unsprinklered side of the mock dorm room fall onto his firefighters, Chief Rubin said, “Those are my guys. Those are humans. Those are flesh and blood and the last thing I wanted to see is even a scratch on their bodies.”

Chief Dennis Rubin takes full responsibility for sprinkler demo mishap. No briefing or backup line. "The Rube" thought it looked like a comedy act.

35 comments


Click here to watch the sprinkler demonstration from Chief Rubin’s point of view.

 Read Paul Peluso’s article at Firehouse.com

Listen to Chief Rubin’s interview

Previous coverage and comment

STATter911.com and 9NEWS NOW have been trying since Thursday to find out details of what went wrong during a sprinkler demonstration in the District of Columbia a day earlier. The gear worn by three firefighters caught fire during the public display at Gallaudet University. One of those firefighters, a sergeant with the DC Fire & EMS Department’s Engine 6, spent the night in the MedStar Burn Unit of the Washington Hospital Center.

A Plexiglas draft curtain set up to hold in the heat and smoke burned and dripped onto the firefighters sent in to put out the fire in the unsprinklered side of the demonstration.

YouTube Preview Image

While details have not been provided to us, Chief Dennis Rubin gave specific information about the errors made during the demonstration in an interview with one of the participants in the event, Ed Comeau with Campus-Firewatch.com. The recording of that interview was made public today during Comeau’s podcast, Fire Marshal’s Corner at Firehouse.com.

Paul Peluso with Firehouse.com has written an article based on the podcast. Here are excerpts:

“Some of the failures on our part — and I’ll take full responsibility — had to do with the idea that we wanted to have a demonstration was impactful so that the equipment would work in a reasonable timeframe,” Rubin said. “Next time we will need a draft curtain that will probably be something that is not as combustible.” (On the video Chief Rubin can be heard calling for the backup line that didn’t exist.)

Rubin said despite technical failures, not following NFPA 1403, the Standard on Live Fire Training Evolutions, is really where the demonstration went wrong.

“I don’t believe we briefed the crew before they went into the structure and I think (that was) a recipe for near-disaster,” he said.

“I stayed pretty busy doing some of the administrative tasks and 20/20 hindsight, I wish I would have had the chance to take a closer look, but we didn’t have a checklist.”

Rubin said another issue was that two hoselines were laid out, but only one was active.

“I thought one was a backup and one was an attack line, but that turned out to be incorrect. The backup line I thought I was looking at turned out to be the feeder line going into the sprinkler system. When it came time for a second crew — which was not on location — to wet down and protect the first crew; that simply wasn’t there.”

Comeau also pointed out that the firefighters went right into the flames, instead of attacking it from a distance.

“I think they wanted to demonstrate their bravery and skill and that was just the wrong place to do it,” Rubin said. “The other horrifying part of the incident was that they were unaware of the fact that they were burning.”

Rubin said that over the years he’s been present for more than a hundred demonstration burns and that his department simply forgot the basics.

“We worked very hard for weeks to prepare for this event . . . It was the perfect setting on the perfect day,” he said. “You can never let your guard down. I just feel horrible about it. Thank goodness it was very minor injuries, but it looked like a comedy act.”

Also, Chief Rubin said in the interview that there was no safety officer in place for the event. The chief says he is going to make sure this does not happen again in his department. Chief Rubin told Ed Comeau he plans to write an article for a national fire service publication on the lessons learned from the demonstration.

We have expressed our concern to DC Fire & EMS Department Director of Communications Pete Piringer about not being able to interview Chief Rubin and not being provided similar details about the incident. Piringer reiterates that the chief has taken full responsibility for the errors made during the event. Piringer said the chief is currently out of town.

UPDATE – Firefighters catch fire during sprinkler demonstration. DC Fire & EMS now confirms one firefighter spent the night in the burn unit.

128 comments

UPDATE on 10/12- Chief Dennis Rubin takes full responsibility for errors. Says demonstration looked like a comedy act.

Usually the biggest worry for a fire chief who has gathered the public and the press together for a sprinkler demonstration is whether the sprinkler head is going to activate as promised. Livingston Fire Protection Inc. made sure that wasn’t a problem during Wednesday’s demonstration using two side by side mock dorm rooms at Gallaudet University in the District of Columbia. It operated at just 12 seconds into the fire.

YouTube Preview Image

It was the fire on the unsprinklered side that occurred minutes earlier that caused a little excitement and had Chief Dennis Rubin asking for someone to put out the firefighters. At about 3:10 on the video above you will see a plastic barrier melt and drip down in a large flaming clump on the three firefighters who were extinguishing the fire.

It was much more obvious to the audience than to the firefighters themselves that something was amiss. All three had plastic burning on their PPE. It took a little more than 30 seconds before the fires were put out.

On Friday, DC Fire & EMS Department officials confirmed that a sergeant from Engine 6 was burned on the cheek and hand. He spent the night in the MedStar Burn Unit of the Washington Hospital Center and was released.